The short answer
- New feeder? Give it time. Birds can take days or a few weeks to find and trust a new feeder.
- Birds suddenly stopped coming? The usual causes are a predator nearby (a hawk or a cat), plenty of natural food in the season, or seed that has gone stale or mouldy.
- Placement matters: birds want cover nearby to flee to, but not so close that a cat can hide in it.
- Most fixes are free: fresh seed, a clean feeder and a better spot solve most cases.
If the feeder is new
1. They haven't found it yet
Birds find food by sight, and a new object in the garden is something to be cautious about at first. It's normal for a new feeder to go untouched for several days, sometimes a few weeks. To speed things up, scatter a little seed on the ground or on a flat surface near the feeder, where birds can see it, and keep the feeder full so the first visitors find food.
2. It's in the wrong place
Small birds approach a feeder in short hops from cover, so a feeder in the middle of an open lawn feels exposed. Put it within a few metres of a shrub, hedge or tree they can dart back to, but not right next to dense low cover where a cat could wait unseen. Near a window, the usual advice is either within about 1 m (3 ft) of the glass or more than 10 m (30 ft) away, which reduces collisions.
3. The seed isn't what they want
Cheap mixes are often padded with filler grains that many birds ignore or throw out. Black-oil sunflower seed is the most widely accepted feeder food. Nyjer (thistle) seed in a finch feeder suits goldfinches, and suet suits woodpeckers, nuthatches and chickadees. If the birds are flicking seed onto the ground, look at what they're leaving behind.
If birds used to come and suddenly stopped
4. A predator is hunting nearby
Hawks learn that feeders gather small birds, and a single hunting visit can keep the regulars away for days. Outdoor cats have the same effect. If you've seen either, move the feeder closer to protective cover and give it time. The birds usually come back once the predator moves on.
5. There's plenty of natural food
In late summer and autumn, seeds, berries and insects are everywhere, and many birds simply eat less at feeders. This is the most common reason for a "sudden" quiet spell, and it reverses on its own when the weather turns cold.
6. The season changed what birds are doing
Birds moult in late summer and tend to keep a low profile while they replace their feathers. In spring and summer, nesting pairs stay close to their territory, and some species migrate away entirely. Feeder traffic naturally rises and falls through the year.
7. The seed has gone stale or mouldy
Seed that sits through wet weather clumps, moulds or goes rancid, and birds avoid it. Mouldy seed can also make them sick. If the feeder has been full for weeks with little activity, empty it, clean it and refill it with a smaller amount of fresh seed.
8. The feeder needs cleaning
Old husks, droppings and damp seed build up quickly. A dirty feeder can spread disease between birds, so clean it every couple of weeks, more often in wet weather, by scrubbing it with hot soapy water and letting it dry fully before refilling. If you see sick-looking birds, take feeders down for a while and clean them thoroughly.
9. Something else is taking over
Squirrels, pigeons or a flock of starlings can empty a feeder or scare smaller birds off. A squirrel baffle, a caged feeder that only lets small birds through, or a feeder with short perches can help the birds you actually want.
Hummingbirds not coming to the feeder?
Hummingbirds are usually put off by spoiled nectar. Make it from one part plain white sugar to four parts water, with no red dye or honey, and change it every few days in hot weather, before it turns cloudy. They also come and go with migration, so a feeder that's quiet in one month may be busy the next. A feeder with red parts helps them find it.
In winter
Cold weather is usually when feeders are busiest, because natural food is scarce. If yours is quiet in winter, check for frozen or wet seed, make sure there's water nearby (a heated birdbath is a gift to birds when everything freezes), and add suet, which gives birds the fat they need on cold nights.
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take birds to find a new feeder?
Anywhere from a day or two to a few weeks. Birds are cautious about new objects. Scattering a little seed nearby and placing the feeder close to cover, such as a shrub or tree, usually speeds things up.
Why did birds suddenly stop coming to my feeder?
The most common reasons are a hawk or cat hunting nearby, plenty of natural food in late summer and autumn, stale or mouldy seed, and a dirty feeder. Fresh seed, a clean feeder and a little patience fix most cases.
Are bird feeders bad for birds?
Not when they're kept clean. The main risk is disease spreading at dirty feeders, so clean them every couple of weeks and take them down for a while if you see sick birds. Placing feeders sensibly near windows also reduces collisions.
Do bird feeders attract rats?
Spilled seed on the ground can. A tray under the feeder, hulled "no-mess" seed that leaves no husks, and only putting out what the birds finish in a day or two all reduce the problem.
If you're shopping for a birder, our gifts for birdwatchers page covers the feeders, seed and binoculars birders actually use (and includes my own shop, disclosed). Thinking about a camera on the feeder? Read whether bird feeder cameras are worth it first.
Spotted a wrong price, a dead listing, or a claim that doesn't hold up? Tell me and I'll fix it — reader corrections have already made these pages better more than once.